He missed his quota for six months straight. Two decades later, Jarrod has worked with brands including Digicel, DHL and Microsoft, generated well over 100 million in revenue, and built one of the most followed sales voices on LinkedIn. He now runs his own sales consultancy and trains sales teams across the Caribbean and beyond.
When he joined us on What I Wish I’d Known About Sales, he explained why the biggest difference between those first six months and everything since wasn’t talent or technique. It was mindset, and the discipline to keep showing up.
Failure Is Direction
We asked Jarrod what he wishes he’d learned in his first year. His answer: that failure was okay.
“In the first six months, I did not achieve my quota. I was doing all the right things. And I remember calling through an entire page, and every single person told me no. And I’m just there like, I’m a failure.”
Over time, it started to click. He worked out what he was doing wrong and adjusted, and he now sees those months as the foundation of everything that followed.
“I learned every single way to do it wrong. So all I had left was the right ways to do it, and that’s what got me my success.”
His comparison is Usain Bolt, who lost races before he became the world’s fastest man. Mistakes are part of learning to cold call, or to sell anything. The point is what you do with them.
“We should never let it discourage us. Failure’s direction. It tells you where to go next.”
Know the Signs of Sales Burnout
A strong sales mindset isn’t the same as working every hour available. Jarrod learned that the hard way too.
“I used to be working probably eighteen hours a day, four hours of sleep, and I was happy in my mind. But I wasn’t listening to the signs that my body was saying: we need rest. We are burnt out.”
He now teaches salespeople to build the self-awareness to spot a slump for what it is: temporary.
“There will always be bad days in sales. It’s seasons. It might not last forever. It could be a week, it could be three days, but your mindset could be the number one thing that changes it.”
Minus Two
When Jarrod runs training sessions, he asks every rep in the room to rate themselves on a scale of one to ten: how would a customer score you? Most people write down a five or a four. Then he gives them the second half of the exercise.
“I say, okay, minus two from that number. And everybody panics. And I say, that’s the number customers see you at.”
His answer is to show up as a ten every time. Not because bad days don’t happen, but because a bad moment shouldn’t be allowed to spill into the next conversation.
“I don’t want to plant a seed of doubt in a customer’s mind just because the previous customer told me no. That’s not fair to this customer. The next call I’m on deserves a ten.”
Buyers notice the difference. On the phone, doubt comes through in your tone of voice. On a video call, it shows on your face.
Lose “Try” and “Hope”
Jarrod has two words he refuses to use in his sales vocabulary.
“I don’t try and hit target, and I don’t hope a customer closes. Those are negative words, in my opinion. So I say, this customer is going to sign this month. I speak about it as if it’s already happening.”
He admits it sounds corny. But he says it has worked for him throughout his career, and since he started his own consultancy. If anything, his regret is that he hasn’t aimed high enough: “You’re not asking for enough.”
Do the Boring
We asked Jarrod what all the top performers he’s worked with have in common. Two words: discipline and structure.
At Digicel, he was one of three top reps. He and another colleague were the extroverts, both hitting around 110% of target. The third was a quiet rep in his early twenties who was hitting 300% a month. Jarrod spent a day on the road with him to find out how.
“It was just a discipline of: I left the house at seven. My meetings are finished by two. Between two and five p.m. is my follow-up, my emails, and making sure the other appointments are scheduled for the rest of the week. It was a system.”
That fixed afternoon block is the part most reps let slip. Consistent follow-up is rarely exciting, but it’s where a lot of deals are won. For Jarrod, it’s a reminder that sales is mostly process.
“Sales is ninety-five percent science to me. The five percent art is you just adding your personality to it. If you’re just winging it, like a cowboy in a saloon shooting everywhere, your chances of hitting target consistently fall considerably.”
His advice is simple: “Do the boring. The boring part is honestly what gets you to your goal. And if you do it every single day, you’ll have a great commission cheque at the end of the month.”
Mind Your Tone
The most underrated skill in sales, according to Jarrod, is the tone of your voice.
“I meet a lot of sales professionals, and when you hear them talk, it’s monotone. Even when you greet the customer, how you play your tone plays an incredible importance. Especially now, as we’re doing cold calls, or it’s a Zoom call, or we’re sending voice notes on LinkedIn, those things matter.”
Too low, and you sound low-energy. Too high, and you come across as aggressive. Jarrod, a former stand-up comedian, also recommends improv training to help reps think and talk on the fly.
He shared one of his favourite call openers, from a cold-calling session with a client who had nothing but a list of phone numbers from a Carnival group in Trinidad: “Hi. We don’t know each other, but we have one thing in common.” It sparked curiosity and answered the “who are you?” question in one line. Jarrod says it drew zero objections.
Bring the Human Back
Jarrod is no technophobe. He thinks technology is making sales better. But the one thing he’d tell reps to stop doing immediately is letting it run the whole sales process for them.
“You do the email sequence and you blast it out to hundreds of customers. You stop caring about who your ideal client profile is. If a robot can do what you do, you haven’t created a unique aspect that is definitively you. You have to bring the human back into sales.”
The reps who stay relevant, he says, will be the ones who use technology to become faster and better for their customers, not the ones who hand the relationship over to it.
Invest in Yourself
Jarrod has a message for sales organisations and one for salespeople.
For companies, it’s that too many underinvest in sales training while setting ambitious targets: “You have big goals, but you’re using the wrong type of fuel. You’re using kerosene in a rocket.”
For individual reps, it’s to stop waiting for permission.
“You should never wait on your company to send you on a conference, to pay for a course, or to buy you a book. You should be doing those things yourself. Trust me, it’s an instant ROI.”
His own reread is Gap Selling by Jim Keenan, which he calls “a game changer for anybody in sales”. It features in our list of the best sales books, and our round-up of personal development books is a good place to look for what to read next.
The same goes for adapting. “You’re only as good as your last month,” Jarrod says, and he has little patience for salespeople who talk about how things were before the pandemic: “I’m trying to hold on to the future.”
About Jarrod Best-Mitchell
Jarrod Best-Mitchell is a sales consultant and trainer with around two decades of experience, working with brands including Digicel, DHL and Microsoft. He is one of the most followed sales professionals on LinkedIn, where he shares content on sales mindset, personal branding and staying relevant as the profession changes.
About This Article
This article is based on Jarrod’s conversation with Lead Forensics for What I Wish I’d Known About Sales, the podcast where sales leaders share the lessons they learned the hard way. Quotes have been lightly edited for clarity. For more from the series, read Tom Boston on authenticity in B2B sales and Zac Thompson on selling like a doctor.
Make Every Call a Ten
Showing up as a ten is easier when you know who you’re talking to and why they might need you. Lead Forensics shows you which companies are visiting your website and which pages they’re reading, so you can prioritise the businesses already showing interest and open every call with something relevant to say.
Book a demo of Lead Forensics to see who’s on your site today.